我正在爲NTRUMLS C庫編寫NTRUMLS C#包裝。我遇到了一個問題,我不相信我通過映射到C庫入口點的外部函數接口正確編組參數數據。將C#結構編譯爲本地C庫
下面是我在ffi.cs
中使用的特定外部函數接口。
using System;
using System.Runtime.InteropServices;
using NTRUMLS.Params;
namespace NTRUMLS.ffi {
public static class ffi {
[DllImport("ntrumls")]
public static extern int pq_gen_key(ParamSet p, out IntPtr privkey_blob_len, out byte[] privkey_blob, out IntPtr pubkey_blob_len, out byte[] pubkey_blob);
}
}
具體ParamSet結構我傳遞在param.cs
,我認爲可能是專門導致了問題。
using System;
using System.Text;
using System.Runtime.InteropServices;
namespace NTRUMLS.Params {
[SerializableAttribute]
[ComVisibleAttribute(true)]
public enum ParamSetId {
Xxx20140508401,
Xxx20140508439,
Xxx20140508593,
Xxx20140508743,
Xxx20151024401,
Xxx20151024443,
Xxx20151024563,
// Xxx20151024509,
Xxx20151024743,
Xxx20151024907,
}
[StructLayout(LayoutKind.Sequential)]
public struct ParamSet {
ParamSetId id;
IntPtr name;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.ByValArray, SizeConst = 3)]
byte[] oid;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.U1)]
byte n_bits;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.U1)]
byte q_bits;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.U2)]
ushort n;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.I1)]
sbyte p;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.I8)]
long q;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.I8)]
long b_s;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.I8)]
long b_t;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.I8)]
long norm_bound_s;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.I8)]
long norm_bound_t;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.U1)]
byte d1;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.U1)]
byte d2;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.U1)]
byte d3;
[MarshalAs(UnmanagedType.U2)]
ushort padded_n;
public ushort get_n() {
return n;
}
public sbyte get_p() {
return p;
}
public byte get_d1() {
return d1;
}
public byte get_d2() {
return d2;
}
public byte get_d3() {
return d3;
}
public uint product_form_bytes() {
return (uint)(4 * (d1 + d2 + d3));
}
public uint polynomial_bytes() {
return (uint)(padded_n * 8);
}
public uint privkey_packed_bytes() {
return (uint)(5 + 2 * ((2 * (d1 + d2 + d3) * n_bits + 7)/8) + ((n +4)/5));
}
public uint pubkey_packed_bytes() {
return (uint)(5 + (n * q_bits + 7)/8 + 64);
}
public ParamSet (ParamSetId ID, IntPtr NAME, byte[] OID, byte N_BITS, byte Q_BITS, ushort N, sbyte P, long Q, long B_S, long B_T, long NORM_BOUND_S, long NORM_BOUND_T, byte D1, byte D2, byte D3, ushort PADDED_N) {
id = ID;
name = NAME;
oid = OID;
n_bits = N_BITS;
q_bits = Q_BITS;
n = N;
p = P;
q = Q;;
b_s = B_S;
b_t = B_T;
norm_bound_s = NORM_BOUND_S;
norm_bound_t = NORM_BOUND_T;
d1 = D1;
d2 = D2;
d3 = D3;
padded_n = PADDED_N;
}
}
public static class ParamSets {
/// <summary>
/// 256 bit security parameter
/// </summary>
public static readonly ParamSet Xxx20140508_743 = new ParamSet(
ParamSetId.Xxx20140508743,
Marshal.StringToHGlobalAuto("Xxx20140508743"),
new byte[] {0xff, 0xff, 0xfc},
10,
20,
743,
3,
1 << 20,
336,
112,
(1 << 19) - 336,
(1 << 19) - 112,
11,
11,
15,
768);
}
}
而這裏是包裝本身NTRUMLSWrapper.cs
。
using NTRUMLS.ffi;
using NTRUMLS.Params;
using System;
using System.Runtime.InteropServices;
namespace NTRUMLS.Library {
public static class NTRUMLSWrapper {
public static KeyPair generate_keys(ParamSet param) {
int pub_len = 0;
int priv_len = 0;
Console.WriteLine("Param N: " + param.get_n());
Console.WriteLine("Param P: " + param.get_p());
Console.WriteLine("Param D1: " + param.get_d1());
Console.WriteLine("Param D2: " + param.get_d2());
Console.WriteLine("Param D3: " + param.get_d3());
GCHandle pub_len_handle = GCHandle.Alloc(pub_len);
GCHandle priv_len_handle = GCHandle.Alloc(priv_len);
IntPtr privkey_blob_len = (IntPtr)pub_len_handle;
IntPtr pubkey_blob_len = (IntPtr)priv_len_handle;
GCHandle handle = GCHandle.Alloc(param);
IntPtr paramater = (IntPtr)handle;
byte[] pv = new byte[priv_len];
byte[] pb = new byte[pub_len];
// GCHandle pv_handle = GCHandle.Alloc(pv);
// GCHandle pb_handle = GCHandle.Alloc(pb);
var result = ffi.ffi.pq_gen_key(param, out privkey_blob_len, out pv, out pubkey_blob_len, out pb);
Console.WriteLine("Result: " + result + " Private Key BLob Length: " + priv_len + " Public Key Blob Lengh: " + pub_len);
if (result != 0)
Console.WriteLine("We got problems");
byte[] privatekey_blob = new byte[privkey_blob_len.ToInt64()];
byte[] pubkey_blob = new byte[pubkey_blob_len.ToInt64()];
result = ffi.ffi.pq_gen_key(param, out privkey_blob_len, out privatekey_blob, out pubkey_blob_len, out pubkey_blob);
if (result != 0)
Console.WriteLine("We got problems");
Console.WriteLine("Result: " + result.ToString() + " Private Key BLob Length: " + privkey_blob_len + " Public Key Blob Lengh: " + pubkey_blob_len);
// byte[] privkeyBytes = new byte[priv_len.ToInt32()];
// byte[] pubkeyBytes = new byte[pub_len.ToInt32()];
return new KeyPair(new PrivateKey(pubkey_blob), new PublicKey(privatekey_blob));;
}
}
public struct PrivateKey {
byte[] ffi_key;
public PrivateKey (byte[] bytes) {
ffi_key = bytes;
}
public byte[] get_bytes() {
return ffi_key;
}
}
public struct PublicKey {
byte[] ffi_key;
public PublicKey (byte[] bytes) {
ffi_key = bytes;
}
public byte[] get_bytes() {
return ffi_key;
}
}
public struct KeyPair {
PublicKey publicKey;
PrivateKey privateKey;
public KeyPair(PrivateKey privKey, PublicKey pubkey)
{
publicKey = pubkey;
privateKey = privKey;
}
public PublicKey getPublic()
{
return publicKey;
}
public PrivateKey getPrivate()
{
return privateKey;
}
}
}
和Program.cs
運行鍵gen測試。
using System;
using NTRUMLS.Library;
using NTRUMLS.Params;
namespace NTRUMLS
{
public class Program
{
public static void Main(string[] args)
{
KeyPair keypair = NTRUMLSWrapper.generate_keys(ParamSets.Xxx20140508_743);
Console.WriteLine("Generated Keys!");
// TODO Sign, than Verify to confirm test
}
}
}
這裏的C函數,我編組到
的pqntrusign.h
int
pq_gen_key(
PQ_PARAM_SET *params,
size_t *privkey_blob_len,
unsigned char *privkey_blob,
size_t *pubkey_blob_len,
unsigned char *pubkey_blob);
在params.h
和頭功能params.c
我認爲,當前的問題是與ParamSet struct
,並正確地將名稱屬性與C結構的const char*name
指針屬性進行匹配。但是,我不完全確定是這種情況。
我修改了NTRUMLS C pqntrusign.c
源文件以打印出log.txt文件並記錄下我傳遞的變量。這是我在int pq_gen_key
函數的開頭添加的代碼片段。
FILE * fp;
fp = fopen ("log.txt", "a+");
fprintf(fp, "Logging made it here variables priv_blob_len_pointer %i pub_blob_len_pointer %i priv_blob_len %i pub_blob_len %i privkey %x pubkey %x \n", privkey_blob_len, pubkey_blob_len, *privkey_blob_len, *pubkey_blob_len, privkey_blob, pubkey_blob);
fprintf(fp, "Logging param ID: %i Oid %x : N: %i Q: %i P %i Padded N: %i D1: %i D2: %i D3: %i \n", P->id, P->OID, P->N, P->q, P->p, P->padded_N, P->d1, P->d2, P->d3);
if(!P || !privkey_blob_len || !pubkey_blob_len)
{
return PQNTRU_ERROR;
}
N = P->N;
padN = P->padded_N;
q = P->q;
p = P->p;
d1 = P->d1;
d2 = P->d2;
d3 = P->d3;
fprintf(fp, "Logging Local N: %i Q: %i P %i Padded N: %i D1: %i D2: %i D3: %i \n", N, q, p, padN, d1, d2, d3);
fclose(fp);
我使用的Fedora 23的x64所以上載於NTRUMLS夏普GitHub上的電流libntrumls.so編譯與片段添加。
從C#控制檯
Param N: 743
Param P: 3
Param D1: 11
Param D2: 11
Param D3: 15
Result: -1 Private Key BLob Length: 0 Public Key Blob Lengh: 0
We got problems
We got problems
Result: -1 Private Key BLob Length: 3 Public Key Blob Lengh: 11
Generated Keys!
輸出輸出從log.txt的
Logging made it here variables priv_blob_len_pointer -923442424 pub_blob_len_pointer -923442432 priv_blob_len -994004096 pub_blob_len -994004064 privkey c8f56510 pubkey f0b0b
Logging param ID: 3 Oid c8f56528 : N: 0 Q: 42678032 P 19 Padded N: 0 D1: 11 D2: 0 D3: 0
Logging Local N: 0 Q: 42678032 P 19 Padded N: 0 D1: 11 D2: 0 D3: 0
Logging made it here variables priv_blob_len_pointer -923442424 pub_blob_len_pointer -923442432 priv_blob_len -994003392 pub_blob_len -994003352 privkey c8f56510 pubkey f0b0b
Logging param ID: 3 Oid c8f56528 : N: 0 Q: 42678032 P 19 Padded N: 0 D1: 11 D2: 0 D3: 0
Logging Local N: 0 Q: 42678032 P 19 Padded N: 0 D1: 11 D2: 0 D3: 0
編輯:
另一個有趣的事情需要注意的是PARAM ID記錄爲3是正確的,因爲枚舉Xxx20140508743
是3,而D1是正確的11.但是,每次我運行該函數輸出記錄的OID是不同的,當它是一組3字節數組在我的ParamSet.Xxx20140508_743
。這導致我相信錯誤發生在編組const char *name
,這是拋出休息。
下面是日誌的另一個輸出。TXT進行比較(這也與加「\ 0」 Marshal.StringToHGlobalAuto("Xxx20140508743\0")
Logging made it here variables priv_blob_len_pointer 982750168 pub_blob_len_pointer 982750160 priv_blob_len -960449664 pub_blob_len -960449632 privkey 3a9395e0 pubkey f0b0b
Logging param ID: 3 Oid 3a9395f8 : N: 0 Q: 38160144 P 19 Padded N: 0 D1: 11 D2: 0 D3: 0
Logging Local N: 0 Q: 38160144 P 19 Padded N: 0 D1: 11 D2: 0 D3: 0
Logging made it here variables priv_blob_len_pointer 982750168 pub_blob_len_pointer 982750160 priv_blob_len -960448960 pub_blob_len -960448920 privkey 3a9395e0 pubkey f0b0b
Logging param ID: 3 Oid 3a9395f8 : N: 0 Q: 38160144 P 19 Padded N: 0 D1: 11 D2: 0 D3: 0
Logging Local N: 0 Q: 38160144 P 19 Padded N: 0 D1: 11 D2: 0 D3: 0
我不相信在Windows DLL工作呢。如果有人不能立即看到在我的代碼的問題或錯誤日誌,編譯和測試所有東西的方向都在NTRUMLS C#README文件中。
謝謝你花時間閱讀這個問題!我知道它很長並且描述性很強,但我不太確定如何縮小它沒有提供所有的信息,因爲我花了很多時間搜索論壇並修改我的代碼以實現這一目標。最好的問候
枚舉可以有不同的尺寸1,2,4,8字節,因此檢查你的C語言編譯器的默認大小。大小可以在c#中設置以匹配c語言。確保'名稱'以'\ 0'結尾。嘗試:Marshal.StringToHGlobalAuto(「Xxx20140508743 \ 0」), – jdweng
不幸的是,添加「\ 0」沒有解決它。然而,另一個有趣的注意事項是參數ID枚舉似乎是編組正確,因爲Xxx2014050874是列表中的第三枚枚舉,並且日誌輸出顯示參數ID爲3,以及D1爲11,這是正確的。但有趣的是每次函數運行時Oid都會改變,並且應該是一個const 3字節數組。我將編輯我的帖子以顯示不同的日誌輸出 – KickTheDragon
變量正在從c#正確傳遞到c,但返回失敗,因爲您破壞了執行堆棧。在.h中,pq_gen_key參數列表包含5個指針,因此在C#中,DllImport必須包含5個IntPtr。然後採取ParamSet p並使用Marshal.StructureToPtr來獲取IntPtr。 – jdweng